Trim & Truss is a referral service. We are not a contractor and we do not do the work.Referral service · not a contractor
Homeowner worksheet

Compare gutter bids on the same scope

Two totals are only comparable when they cover the same work. Copy this worksheet and fill it from up to three written proposals.

The gutter service guide covers materials, costs and general questions. This worksheet is for recording what each actual proposal includes, so differences in scope stay visible.

The worksheet

Copy this worksheet into a note or document you can edit. Label bids A, B, and C with the contractor name and proposal date, then add answers from each written proposal. Ask the installer to clarify missing details. These questions do not imply that every installer provides every service.

Show full text for manual copying

Bid A contractor / proposal date: [add details]

Bid B contractor / proposal date: [add details]

Bid C contractor / proposal date: [add details]

1. Which roof-edge runs are included, and what measured gutter length is quoted for each?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

2. How many stories are involved, and what access assumptions or access-related charges are included?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

3. What gutter material, profile, size, and sectional or seamless construction are quoted?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

4. How many downspouts are included, where will they go, and where will each discharge? Are extensions or other drainage work included?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

5. Are guards included, optional, or excluded? If included, what type and which runs?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

6. Are existing gutters and downspouts removed? Is hauling and disposal included?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

7. If fascia damage is uncovered, is any repair included? If not, how will the scope and added charge be agreed before work continues?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

8. What is expressly excluded or left for a separate quote?

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

9. What is the written total for the stated scope? List optional items separately.

Bid A: [add answer]
Bid B: [add answer]
Bid C: [add answer]

Read the answers

Compare the included work before comparing totals. If measured lengths, downspout discharge, or removal differ, ask bidders to explain the difference rather than treating the totals as interchangeable. Home size is only a rough proxy for gutter length; the roof-edge runs in the bid are the useful comparison. This Old House identifies material, home size, roof complexity, and number of stories as cost factors, but those factors do not establish a local price for this house.

Check where water will go after it leaves each downspout. A drawing or marked photo can make different discharge plans easier to compare. Keep guard options and possible fascia work visible as separate scope questions. Do not assume a blank means included. For Maryland residential work that falls under home-improvement law, the Maryland Home Improvement Commission says contractors contracting directly with homeowners for covered work must be MHIC licensed; a homeowner can check the contractor's current status with the Commission. This is not a claim that every gutter job has the same legal scope.

Sources and limits

This worksheet is informational. Trim & Truss has not measured this home, inspected its gutters, or obtained these bids. Fill the answer lines from the actual written proposals.