Trim & Truss is a referral service. We are not a contractor and we do not do the work.Referral service · not a contractor
Local guide · Baltimore area

How to compare roof repair quotes in Baltimore

Two repair quotes for the same leak can describe two different jobs. A worksheet for lining them up, the questions to send both roofers, and the contract and permit facts to check.

Trim & Truss editorial · Updated October 22, 2026 · Every figure is linked to its source below

Key takeaways

  • Compare the diagnosis before the price. If two roofers name different sources for the leak, they are quoting different repairs.
  • Write "not stated" wherever a quote is silent, then ask both roofers the same questions and compare the revised versions.
  • Maryland requires a written, signed contract that names the contractor’s license number, the work, the materials and approximate dates. A contractor cannot take more than one-third of the price as a deposit.
  • Baltimore City says minor repairs usually need no permit unless something is completely replaced or significantly changed. Get the answer for your own job in writing.

The short answer

Two repair quotes for the same leak can describe two different jobs. One might include the flashing next to the leak and the other only the roof surface you can see. Get each roofer’s diagnosis and scope in writing, put them side by side on the worksheet below, and send both roofers the same follow-up questions before you compare totals.

Start with the diagnosis

Ask each roofer where they think the water is getting in, what they saw that points there, which area they plan to open or repair, and what they can’t know until the roof is open. Photos and written notes make the explanations easier to compare, though nobody can see what’s under the membrane or shingles from the top.

If the two roofers name different sources, sort that out first. Ask each one to respond to the other’s explanation. Until they agree on the problem, you are pricing two different repairs.

The worksheet

Copy this table and fill in one column per proposal. Where a quote says nothing, write “not stated” and ask for a revised written scope.

Roof repair quote comparison
ItemWhat to write downQuestion if it’s missing or different
Contractor and licenseBusiness name and MHIC license numberDoes the name match the state license record?
DiagnosisWhere the water is getting in, and the evidenceAre both quotes fixing the same suspected source?
Repair areaRoof type, which sections, rough dimensionsExactly where does the work start and stop?
Existing materialLayers present; what comes off, what staysWhat happens to damaged material next to the repair?
Flashing, penetrations, drainageWhich walls, pipes, vents, drains or scuppers are includedIs the flashing at the leak part of the job?
MaterialsProduct and specificationIs it the same product, or an equivalent to it?
Access and protectionLadders, staging, covering adjoining surfacesHow do they reach the roof and protect the house and neighbors?
Cleanup and disposalWho hauls debrisIs cleanup in the price or extra?
PermitWho checks, who applies, permit numberWho confirms the rule for this address and scope?
Hidden conditionsHow rotten deck or framing is handledIs there a written unit price or a process for approving it?
Change ordersHow added work is described and approvedWill added work be approved in writing before it starts?
DatesApproximate start and completionWhat could move the dates?
WarrantyWorkmanship and material terms, who backs eachWhat is excluded, and is it in writing?
PaymentsDeposit and each later payment, with timingIs the deposit at or under one-third of the price?

Our worksheet. It is a way to organize two proposals, not a legal checklist or an inspection of your roof.

The Baltimore-area roofing guide covers roof types and costs, and the flat roof article lists what a full flat-roof replacement quote should name. This worksheet is for repairs, where the bigger risk is two quotes that quietly cover different work.

Questions to send both roofers

Send each roofer the same list: every blank and every mismatch from the worksheet. Ask for an updated written proposal back.

Some questions depend on the house. If yours is a rowhome with a parapet or party wall, a rear drain, a roof deck or a narrow alley, ask whether the flashing at the wall, the drain, protection for the deck and access are included. The flat roof article explains why those details are where flat roofs tend to leak. On a pitched roof, ask which shingles and which flashings are being replaced.

Then ask how each roofer will handle damage they find once the roof is open. A written allowance or unit price for deck repair is different from work that is already included, so note which one you have. Get the change-order process in writing so you can tell the original job from later additions.

License and contract

Maryland law says a person must have a contractor license to act as a home improvement contractor in the state, with exceptions written into the law (§ 8-301). Look up the license and check that the name matches the proposal. A license tells you the state licensed the firm. It doesn’t tell you the work is good.

The contract itself has to be in writing, legible and signed by each party. It must give the contractor’s name, address, phone and license number, the approximate dates the work will start and be substantially complete, and a description of the work and materials. You must get a copy signed by the contractor before work begins (§ 8-501). The Maryland Home Improvement Commission adds that a contractor cannot accept more than one-third of the contract price as a deposit, and no payment before the contract is signed (MHIC contract guidance). The hub’s hiring checks link to the license search.

The permit question

Baltimore City says minor repairs usually don’t need permits unless the item is completely replaced or significantly changed, and that renovations, modifications and reconstructions always need one (city building permits page). That is general guidance. Ask who will confirm the rule for your actual scope and address, who applies if a permit is needed, and when you’ll get the permit number. Outside city limits, the county office sets the rules; our city and county permit guide explains the difference.

Pick a roofer once you can say, for each proposal, what gets repaired, what is left out, and how extra work gets approved. Until then, a lower total on a vaguer scope isn’t comparable to the other quote.

Common questions

Should I take the lowest roof repair quote?

Only once the quotes describe the same job. A lower total that leaves out the flashing, the drain or the cleanup is a smaller job, so it will look cheaper. Fill in the worksheet, ask both roofers about every blank, and compare the revised proposals.

Does a roof repair in Baltimore City need a permit?

Sometimes. The city says minor repairs usually do not need a permit unless the item is completely replaced or significantly changed, and that renovations, modifications and reconstructions always do. Have the roofer confirm the answer for your actual scope and address, and get the permit number if one is issued.

What does a Maryland home improvement contract have to include?

Under Business Regulation § 8-501 it must be in writing, legible and signed by each party. It must list the contractor’s name, address, phone and license number, the approximate start and substantial-completion dates, and a description of the work and the materials. You must get a copy signed by the contractor before work begins.

How we made this guide. We read Maryland’s home improvement law, the state commission’s contract guidance and Baltimore City’s permit page, and linked each one. We did not review anyone’s actual quotes or inspect any roof, and we do not install roofs. Trim & Truss is a referral service and may be paid by pros we refer; that does not change what is written here.