Trim & Truss is a referral service. We are not a contractor and we do not do the work.Referral service · not a contractor
Cost guide · 2026

Roof replacement cost in 2026

What a new roof costs by material and size, why labor is most of the bill, and how to read a roofing estimate.

Trim & Truss editorial · Updated November 17, 2026 · Every figure is linked to its source below

Key takeaways

  • National average in 2026: This Old House puts a new 2,000 sq ft roof at $29,909, and a 2,000 sq ft asphalt shingle roof at $10,319. Fixr puts a typical shingle roof near $14,500.
  • Material is the biggest lever. At 2,000 sq ft, published baseline figures are about $10,300 for asphalt, $26,300 for wood shake, $38,600 for metal, and $44,400 for clay tile.
  • About half of surveyed homeowners (52%) paid $5,001 to $20,000 for their new roof.
  • Labor was about 65% of total project cost in the survey, so steep pitch and complex shapes move the price more than shingle brand.
  • Hidden decking damage is the usual surprise: 23% of homeowners who found it paid more than their original estimate, versus 13% who did not.
  • Most homeowners paid about what they expected: 79% said the final cost was about what they expected.

The short answer

The average roof replacement cost in 2026 is about $29,909 for a 2,000 square-foot roof, according to This Old House’s national guide (updated October 2026). For asphalt shingles, the most common material, the same guide puts a 2,000 square-foot roof at $10,319. Fixr, which publishes national cost ranges, lists a typical shingle roof near $14,500, with most projects between $8,000 and $36,000 depending on roof size and material.

Reported spending sits lower than that all-material average. In This Old House’s 2026 survey of 1,000 homeowners who replaced a roof in the last five years, about half (52%) paid between $5,001 and $20,000.

Why the spread? This Old House does not break its overall average down by material, and its asphalt figure is a baseline for builder-grade shingles, medium labor and a standard low-slope roof. Real roofs have pitch, valleys, vents and a tear-off, and costlier materials such as metal and tile pull an all-material average up. Labor rates also differ by region, so a roof in Tacoma, Salt Lake City or Baltimore can land well above or below a national figure. Use these numbers to sanity-check a written quote. They are published national averages, not prices from us or from any contractor.

Cost by material

Roofing cost by material, 2,000 sq ft roof
MaterialCost per sq ftTotal, 2,000 sq ftTypical lifespan
Asphalt shingles$5.16$10,31930 to 35 years
Wood shake$13.15$26,30230 to 50 years
Metal$19.30$38,59340 to 70 years
Clay tile$22.21$44,42350 to 100 years

Source: This Old House using Homewyse data (guide updated October 2026). Builder-grade materials, medium labor costs, low-slope and standard-shaped roofs.

Aerial view of a house with a gray standing-seam metal roof
A standing-seam metal roof. In the table's national baseline, metal costs roughly three to four times as much per square foot as asphalt. Photo: Wikideas1, CC0 1.0, source

Asphalt shingles are the most common material (47% of surveyed homeowners chose them) because they are inexpensive, lightweight, and easy to install. Heavy materials such as clay tile may need a structural engineer to confirm the house can carry the extra load.

What a 30-year comparison can tell you

The table above puts a 2,000-square-foot asphalt roof at $10,319 and a metal roof at $38,593. Those are This Old House's published national baselines for builder-grade materials, medium labor, a standard roof shape and low slope. They are not Baltimore bids or a price for a specified metal system.

For a thought experiment, hold those 2026 national prices fixed and suppose the asphalt roof is replaced once at year 30. One asphalt installation is $10,319; two are $20,638. One metal installation is $38,593, which is $17,955 more than that two-installation asphalt example. A replacement at year 30 is an assumption, not a prediction that the published 30–35-year asphalt roof will fail within the comparison period. A future roof will not necessarily cost today's price, and this arithmetic leaves out repairs, maintenance, financing, utility bills and resale value. It does not establish which roof will cost less in your home over 30 years.

The published lifespan ranges in that guide are broad: 30–35 years for asphalt and 40–70 for metal. Neither is a promise for the product, installation or roof you're considering. Ask for the exact material and separate product and workmanship warranty terms in writing. A longer warranty is not itself a prediction of service life.

If someone includes cooling savings in a metal-roof proposal, ask for the proposed product's solar reflectance and thermal emittance. EPA's cool-roof guidance ties cooling performance to those properties, not to metal alone; winter heating effects can also matter. This comparison assigns no Baltimore energy savings or resale premium. On a flat or low-slope rowhome roof, confirm which systems suit the roof before comparing asphalt and metal; the Baltimore flat-roof guide covers that separate choice.

Build your own comparison from two written proposals

The national example above is not a reason to choose one material. For a decision about this house, begin with two complete proposals and compare the same roof area, work and time period. Leave a field blank when the information is missing. A blank identifies a question; it should not be filled with a guessed average just to finish a spreadsheet.

  1. Define the two systems. Record the exact asphalt product in one column and the exact metal system in the other. “Metal” is not a product specification. Ask each installer to explain whether the proposed system suits the roof shape and slope and to identify the installation instructions used.
  2. Match the starting scope. List removal, disposal, protection of the property, underlayment, flashing, ventilation and cleanup. Mark every item included, excluded or not stated. If one proposal assumes removal and another assumes installation over an existing roof, ask about that difference before comparing totals.
  3. Make hidden-work terms visible. Ask how damaged decking or other conditions discovered during removal will be documented, authorized and priced. Record any quoted unit prices beside the conditions that trigger them. An allowance and a fixed included amount are not the same thing.
  4. Separate initial price from future assumptions. Put the current complete proposal total on its own line. Future repairs, maintenance and possible replacement belong on separate lines with the source and date of each assumption. A future estimate is not a contractor commitment unless the agreement actually says so.
  5. Read the warranty documents. Keep product and workmanship coverage in separate rows. Record who responds, exclusions, maintenance requirements and any transfer conditions. Do not substitute the number of warranty years for a predicted replacement year.

The National Roofing Contractors Association's homeowner resources emphasize that no roofing material is best for every application and that workmanship and maintenance matter alongside material choice. Its guidance is a reason to ask about the complete system, not a material ranking for your property. Trim & Truss has not inspected this roof or verified either proposal.

Use three scenarios, not one confident forecast

First write a scenario with only the initial installed quotes and the future work you can actually substantiate. Then make a second scenario that includes a possible asphalt replacement at a clearly labelled assumed year. Finally, test a different replacement year or repair allowance. Use the same comparison end date throughout. These are sensitivity checks, not probabilities or predictions about either roof.

For each scenario, keep the arithmetic transparent: initial installed quote, plus the repair and maintenance costs you chose to include, plus any assumed replacement within the period. If you use future prices, state whether they are held in today's dollars or adjusted using an explicit assumption. Do not mix the two approaches. This guide supplies no inflation rate, discount rate, financing offer or future roof price.

Check the boundary at the end of the period. Replacing a roof on the final day of a 30-year comparison is different from paying for a replacement earlier and using it for many years. Show that timing rather than hiding it in a total. Likewise, do not credit a remaining roof with a resale value unless you have a stated, supportable basis. Neither a warranty term nor a national lifespan range tells you what a buyer will pay.

Keep energy and resale claims outside the base case

If a bidder proposes energy savings, ask for the exact product ratings, the local conditions and the method behind the estimate. EPA's cool-roof guidance discusses solar reflectance and thermal emittance and notes that heating effects can matter in colder climates. A material name alone is not evidence of annual savings for this house. Put an unsupported saving at “not established,” not at a convenient dollar value.

Handle resale claims the same way. Keep them separate from out-of-pocket project costs and identify their source and limits. A general remodeling report does not guarantee a price premium when you sell. If the preferred option changes only when you add an uncertain saving or premium, that uncertainty belongs beside the recommendation.

Questions to resolve before choosing

Ask which differences in the proposals would remain even if both used the same covering. Ask what inspection is needed before the scope can be finalized, who confirms permit requirements and what happens if the existing roof differs from the assumptions. Use our written roof-quote comparison guide to organize those answers. For a flat or low-slope roof, start with a suitability check rather than assuming a pitched-roof shingle comparison applies.

How we made this comparison: We expanded the published national-cost example into a proposal and scenario worksheet using the linked This Old House, NRCA and EPA guidance. We did not collect local bids, model this home's energy use or predict its roof life. Trim & Truss is an educational referral service, not the installer; independent providers may pay for referrals. The worksheet helps identify unanswered questions, not select a roof without inspection.

Cost by roof size

The average roof in the US is about 1,700 square feet, according to the Census Bureau figure cited by This Old House, and the baseline asphalt price at that size is $8,772. Note that roof area is not the same as floor area: pitch, overhangs, and shape make a roof larger than the footprint under it.

Total cost by roof area (This Old House / Homewyse baseline)
Roof areaAsphalt shinglesWood shakeMetalClay tile
1,000 sq ft$5,160$13,150$19,300$22,210
1,500 sq ft$7,740$19,725$28,950$33,315
2,000 sq ft$10,320$26,300$38,600$44,420
2,500 sq ft$12,900$32,875$48,250$55,525
3,000 sq ft$15,480$39,450$57,900$66,630

Ballpark calculator

Roof ballpark

Published-average ballpark$10,320

Rates are This Old House / Homewyse baseline figures per square foot of roof area for builder-grade materials. This is arithmetic on a published average, not a quote. Local labor, pitch, hidden damage, and permits can move it a lot. A pro who sees the house will give you a real number.

Why labor dominates the bill

In the This Old House survey, 65% of total project cost was labor. Roofing labor averages about $75 per hour according to the Roofers Guild, though it swings with pitch, access, and regional demand. A roof with many planes, valleys, dormers, or skylights creates more waste and more hours. A steep roof, or one more than two stories up, needs extra safety equipment and goes slower.

A roofer working on a shingle roof over a brick house
Pitch, height, and complexity drive labor, which is most of a roofing bill. Photo: Patsy Lynch / FEMA, Public domain (US government work), source

What else is on the bill

A shingle price per square foot is not the whole job. Look for these items on any estimate:

  • Tear-off and disposal. Contractors typically charge to remove and dispose of old roofing and debris. More roof planes means more waste.
  • Underlayment. Typically asphalt-saturated felt over the wood decking as a moisture barrier. Synthetic underlayment is common too.
  • Ice and water barrier. In regions prone to ice dams or heavy rain, an additional membrane adds material and labor.
  • Drip edge and flashing. Metal trim at the edges, and flashing where the roof meets chimneys, walls, and dormers. Worn flashing and pipe boots let water in.
  • Ventilation. Roof or ridge vents keep attic air moving and protect the roof’s lifespan.
  • Decking repair. Damaged wood decking or framing has to be replaced. This is the line most likely to change the price.
  • Gutters. If gutters must come off, factor in reattaching or replacing them.
  • Permits. Depending on local code, permits are an add-on cost that may not show up in the original estimate.
The surprise to plan for. In the This Old House survey, 23% of homeowners who had hidden or unexpected roof damage paid more than their original estimate, compared with 13% of those who did not. Ask for a written price to replace decking by the sheet or square foot before work begins.

Repair or replace?

A leak does not automatically require replacement. NRCA notes that loose flashing or damage confined to one section may be repairable; broader roof-system failure needs a different assessment. Ask what failed, what was inspected and what a proposed repair would leave unresolved. Age alone is not a diagnosis.

Use our roof repair or replacement decision checklist to record the evidence, compare complete scopes and identify what would change the recommendation.

Ways to save

  • Check insurance first. Weather damage or a downed tree may be covered. Contact your insurer before you sign, not after.
  • Bundle. If gutters or exterior painting are also on your list, some contractors price bundles lower.
  • Compare written quotes. Get at least two, and make sure they describe the same scope.
  • Payment terms. Some contractors give a better price for a larger deposit or full payment at completion. Get any agreed terms in the contract.

What the survey says about outcomes: 79% of homeowners said their final cost matched their original estimate, 73% said the roofer finished within the original timeline, and 91% were satisfied or very satisfied with their new roof. Nearly half (46%) said the project took three to seven days.

Reading a roofing estimate

  1. Roof area and how it was measured. Square feet or squares (100 sq ft), by tape, drone, or satellite.
  2. Exact materials. Shingle brand, line, and color; underlayment type; ice and water barrier locations.
  3. Tear-off or overlay. And what the pro does if they find a second or third layer.
  4. Flashing, drip edge, and vents. Replaced or reused, line by line.
  5. Decking. A written price for replacing damaged boards.
  6. Permit, dumpster, and cleanup. Who handles each, including magnet sweeps for nails.
  7. Warranties. The manufacturer warranty and the installer’s workmanship warranty, both in writing.

For the broader project overview, see our roof replacement service page.

Roofing in the Baltimore area? National averages hide a lot of local detail. Many Baltimore rowhomes have flat or low-slope roofs, and the city and county have different permit rules. See our Baltimore-area roofing guide, with companion articles on flat roof options for rowhomes and roof permits in Baltimore City and County.

Common questions

What is the average roof replacement cost in 2026?

This Old House’s guide, updated October 2026, puts the national average at $29,909 for a 2,000 square-foot roof and $10,319 for a 2,000 square-foot asphalt shingle roof. Fixr puts a typical shingle roof near $14,500, with most projects between $8,000 and $36,000. These are national figures from published sources, not quotes, and local labor rates move them in either direction.

How much does a new roof cost for a 2,000 sq ft roof?

This Old House’s material table, built on Homewyse data for builder-grade materials, medium labor and a standard low-slope roof, shows $10,319 for asphalt shingles, $26,302 for wood shake, $38,593 for metal, and $44,423 for clay tile for 2,000 sq ft of roof area, not house floor area.

What did homeowners actually pay?

In This Old House’s 2026 survey of 1,000 homeowners who replaced a roof within the last five years, about half (52%) reported paying $5,001 to $20,000, and 79% said the final cost was about what they expected.

Why are the numbers from different sites so different?

They measure different things: survey averages, baseline database figures, and national ranges. Roof size, pitch, shape, material grade, tear-off, and local labor all move the price. Use the figures to see the range, then get written quotes.

Repair or replace?

A leak does not automatically require replacement. NRCA notes that loose flashing or damage in one section can cause leaks. Ask for an inspection that establishes the cause, extent and condition of the remaining roof; age alone is not a diagnosis.

Can new shingles go over old ones?

Most building codes allow two layers of asphalt shingles, and an overlay is often faster and cheaper. It can make sense for a roof in good shape with localized damage. It hides the deck from inspection, so many pros prefer tear-off.

Will homeowners insurance cover a new roof?

It may cover damage from a storm or a fallen tree. In the This Old House survey, weather-related damage was the most common reason for replacement (40%). Wear and age are usually not covered. Check your policy and call your insurer before you sign.

How we made this guide. We compiled published figures and linked every one. We did not collect quotes, and these are national numbers, so your local price will differ. Trim & Truss is a referral service and may be paid by pros we refer; that does not change the figures here.